Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders in Gaylord, MI
There’s something about Gaylord that makes food taste better. Maybe it’s the crisp air, the way a snowy evening practically begs for something hot and cheesy, or the simple fact that people here know how to appreciate a good meal. Whatever the reason, we’re proud to be the kind of grinder pizza restaurant that feels right at home in Northern Michigan.
At Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders, we’ve built our reputation on one big idea: if we’re going to serve it, we’re going to make it the right way. That means we bake our bread in-house, make our bread, dough and sauce from scratch, and stack every pizza and grinder with quality meats, cheeses, and vegetables you can actually taste. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, feeding the family after a busy day, or planning an easy dinner night, we’re here to keep it delicious, filling, and simple.
A Local Favorite With Deep Roots
Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders is proud to be a family-owned, veteran-owned business with a tradition that stretches back over 70 years. We’re also honored to be part of the Gaylord community as Chamber of Commerce members, and we offer veteran discounts as a small way of giving back.
We’re not here to be “just another pizza place.” We’re here to be your go-to spot for fresh-made food, friendly service, and the kind of comfort meal that hits the spot year-round in Northern Michigan.
See What Customers are Saying
A Pizza Restaurant With a Bread Baker’s Soul
A lot of places call themselves a pizza restaurant, but what makes us different is what happens behind the scenes. Early each morning, we bake small batches of artisan bread from scratch so every grinder comes out hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. We also make our bread, dough and sauce in-house, which gives our pizzas that fresh-baked, crave-worthy taste you can’t fake.
It’s the kind of care you can taste in every bite, whether you’re sitting down for a slice or picking up dinner to bring back home near Otsego Lake, Aspen Park, or out by the ski hills.
Pizza, Grinders, and the “What Are We Craving Tonight?” Menu
We get it, choosing dinner isn’t always easy. One person wants pizza, someone else wants a sandwich, and someone’s definitely in the mood for wings. That’s why our menu covers all the bases, with plenty of favorites to keep everyone happy.
Our Signature Pizzas
(Thin, Regular, or Deep Dish)
We bake our pizzas hot and loaded with our four-cheese blend: mozzarella, Muenster, white Cheddar, and provolone. Choose thin crust, regular crust, or deep dish when you want something extra hearty.
Some of our most-loved specialty pizzas include:
- Mancino’s Pride Pizza with pepperoni, ham, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and black olives
- Mancino’s Super Pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions
- Meat Lovers’ Pizza with pepperoni, ham, bacon, sausage, and ground beef
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza made with ranch sauce instead of pizza sauce
- BBQ Chicken Pizza with zesty BBQ sauce and a sprinkle of cilantro
- Chicken Alfredo Pizza with creamy Alfredo sauce, chicken, bacon, and mushrooms
- Bacon Pickle Pizza for anyone who loves bold flavor
- Mancino’s Hawaiian Pizza with ham, bacon, and pineapple
- Mancino’s BLT Pizza finished with lettuce and tomatoes after baking
- Mancino’s Veggie Pizza piled with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives
And if you want that cozy comfort-food vibe, our deep dish pizzas are worth the wait, especially during those long winter nights when the snow’s coming down and you’d rather stay in.
Oven-Baked Grinders You’ll Dream About
Our grinders are baked on our freshly made bread and served hot, with our signature four-cheese blend melted into every bite. We offer mini 4.5 inch grinders, 9-inch grinders, and 18-inch grinders for when you’re feeding a crew.
A few customer favorites include:
- Italian Grinder
- Steak Grinder
- Pizza Grinder
- Meatball Grinder
- Chicken Bacon Club Grinder
- Reuben Grinder
- French Dip Grinder with our home-made au jus
- BBQ Pork Grinder
- The Lumberjack Grinder for serious appetites
Whether you’re grabbing lunch between errands on M-32 or bringing dinner back home after a day outside, our grinders deliver that hot, baked, melty goodness every time.
Wings, Appetizers, Salads, and Pasta for the Full Spread
Sometimes you want more than pizza or a grinder, and we’re ready for that too.
Our menu includes:
- Bone-in and boneless wings in multiple sizes
- Garlic Cheese Bread and breadsticks (with pizza sauce or ranch)
- Full order fries for an easy side
- Fresh salads like Chef, Greek, Antipasto, Grilled Chicken, Veggie, and Dinner Salad
- Baked pasta meals, including Chicken & Mushroom Alfredo, Meatball Pasta, and our Basic Red Pasta, all served with home-made garlic bread
And yes, we’ve got dessert too. Our cinnamon sticks and homemade chocolate chip cookie are the perfect finish, especially if you’re ending the night with a movie and staying warm inside.
Pizza Delivery That Makes Dinner Easy in Gaylord
We love being the place you come to hang out, but we also know some nights are “stay home and relax” nights. That’s why we make pizza delivery simple and convenient for locals who want a hot meal without leaving the house.
Whether you’re winding down after work, feeding a hungry family, or trying to avoid cooking during a busy week, we’re ready to bring your favorites to you.
Looking for the Best Pizza Deals? We’ve Got You
Everyone loves a great meal, but getting a great value makes it even better. If you’re hunting for the best pizza deals in Gaylord, our specials make it easier to feed a group, handle game-day cravings, or turn a random Tuesday into pizza night.
We keep things straightforward, satisfying, and worth coming back for.
Order Your Favorites Fast With Pizza Order Online
When you’re hungry, waiting is the worst. We make it easy to get your meal started with pizza order online options so you can choose what you want, customize it, and get it on the way without the back-and-forth.
It’s perfect for:
- Quick lunches between work and errands
- Family dinners when everyone wants something different
- Weekend meals after exploring trails or hitting the slopes
- Easy food plans for guests or gatherings
Events That Keep Your Whole Group Happy
If you’re hosting an event in Gaylord, food is always a big deal. Our catering makes it easier to feed a crowd without stressing over the kitchen.
Our Party in a Box is a popular option and includes 4 full grinders, cut into smaller sandwiches that are easy to serve and share. It’s a great fit for:
- Game days and watch parties
- Office lunches
- Family get-togethers
- School events and team meals
- Holiday gatherings
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, we offer pizza delivery through Door Dash so you can enjoy your favorite pizzas, grinders, and more without leaving home.
We make our dough, bread, and sauce in-house. That fresh-baked approach gives our pizzas and grinders a flavor you can’t get from a place using pre-made ingredients.
Yes. Ordering pizza online makes it quick and easy to get your meal started, whether you’re ordering lunch or planning dinner for the family. 15 minutes to 30 minutes for pick up. Click here to place an online order
Absolutely. We serve oven-baked grinders, wings, salads, baked pasta, appetizers, and desserts, so there’s something for everyone.
Yes, we do. Our event delivery options are great for group meals and local events, and our Party in a Box is a popular pick for feeding a crowd. Click here to order delivery
Your Favorite Gaylord Pizza Night Starts Here
When you’re craving something hot, filling, and made the right way, we’re ready to take care of dinner. At Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders, we bring together fresh-baked tradition and big-time flavor, all in a way that fits life here in Gaylord. From a deep dish pizza on a snowy evening to grinders fresh out of the oven after a day out in Northern Michigan, we love being the spot you can count on. Swing in, choose pizza delivery when you want to stay cozy at home, or place your pizza order online and let us handle the rest.
Proudly providing fresh pizzas and grinders to Gaylord, MI and the following surrounding areas:
Bellaire, MI | Boyne City, MI | Charlevoix, MI | East Jordan, MI | Elmira, MI | Grayling, MI | Indian River, MI | Johannesburg, MI | Kalkaska, MI | Lewiston, MI | Mancelona, MI | Petoskey, MI | Vanderbilt, MI | Wolverine, MI